This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Hamilton Ontario Citizenship Ceremony | Joey Coleman from Hamilton, Canada, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

But first, a movie. Pride (2014), based on the true story, is about a group of gay and lesbian activists who raised money for Welsh mining communities during Britain’s 1984-85 miners’ strike, after they realized the police had stopped harassing them because they were harassing the miners instead. Early in the film, after getting no response from the miners’ union, the activists reach out to Onllwyn, a small mining village in Wales, and offer them their donations directly. 

Dai, one of the striking miners, heads down to London to collect the money. He admits they're the first gay people he's met. Mark, the group's leader, tells him he's also the first miner they've met. Later, thanking a packed gay bar, Dai tells the crowd that what they've given the miners is more than money. It's friendship, and the discovery of "a friend you never knew existed."

Watching the film reminded me how rarely we truly see the world through another community’s eyes until something pushes us together. The distance between groups can feel vast, and it often takes a shared moment—sometimes uncomfortable, sometimes unexpected—to reveal how much we still have to learn about one another.

In Canada, I rarely see our immigration debate create the kinds of encounters that force people to see each other differently. Instead, it usually sets up a contest: newcomers on one side, long-time residents/Canadians by birth on the other. The conversation narrows to whose needs matter more, rather than what we might have in common.

Too often, when I hear people make the case for immigrants, they reach for the same examples: the doctor who fills a gap in our hospitals, the entrepreneur who starts a business, the newcomer whose achievements are supposed to reassure us that their presence benefits us. These stories do some good, but they also act as shorthand—a way to prove worth, not one that allows us to see people as the humans they are in this shared cosmos.

When I was working on a narrative strategy in Calgary earlier this year, I kept running into this approach. Most of the well-meaning immigration messaging I saw relied on one of two frames. Either it was economic—immigrants belong because they fill jobs, pay taxes, and help the economy grow. Or it was hospitality, with Calgarians cast as the hosts and immigrants as the guests. Sometimes it was both at once.

People use these frames with good intentions. But the economic lens makes belonging conditional, tied to being useful. The hospitality lens keeps newcomers in the role of guests, even as they help build the city around them.

When we lead with what immigrants contribute, as we so often do, we’re really asking people to judge whether newcomers are worth keeping. We spend our energy defending their value, but we rarely stop to ask what shapes the concerns of the people we’re trying to reach.

❝

If our immigration debate forces people to choose between newcomers and those already here, it’s not hard to see which side most will pick.

But we have the polling numbers

Yes, polling is useful in some way, but we often obsess over the headline numbers. The 2026 Canadian Diversity Study is such a great example. 71% of respondents agreed that Canada has too much immigration. But the study also asked whether Canada should fully welcome immigrants from around the world, and the majority split. 36% of all respondents said immigration was too high and agreed with that welcoming vision. 

Another 32% said immigration was too high and disagreed with that welcoming vision. Two groups agreed about immigration levels and gave very different answers about the kind of country they wanted Canada to be.

For that 36 percent, the ideal is fewer arrivals but a Canada that still welcomes people from around the world. Telling them another story about an immigrant doctor probably just repeats something they already know.

The real question is what’s actually troubling them about immigration. Is it the cost of housing, or a sense that the system isn’t being managed well enough?

For the other 32 percent, stories about successful immigrants probably won’t change anything. But the headline number lumps these two very different groups together, so we end up making the case for newcomers to people who never actually questioned their value in the first place.

I find the political scientist Alexander Kustov’s work useful here. He argues that the people whose views shift are “the large middle,” people who “care about newcomers but put their own compatriots first,” and who back immigration “when they can see it working for the country.”

If our immigration debate forces people to choose between newcomers and those already here, it’s not hard to see which side most will pick. When faced with that choice, many will side with the neighbour waiting hours in the emergency room, even if the newcomer doctor could help shorten the wait.

The answer, I think, is to find a way for those already here and those arriving to see themselves on the same side. That’s where I landed in my work on Calgary’s narrative strategy. The Calgarian whose family has been here for generations and the one who arrived last spring often end up waiting in the same line for the same things.

Ukrainian aid Red Cross sign, Pearson International Airport, Toronto, Ontario, Canada | Cory Doctorow from Beautiful Downtown Burbank, USA, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

We need a reason to meet

In Pride, the activists got involved because they recognized something of their own situation with the police in the miners. Friendship grew over time, but it started with one group noticing they shared the same struggle.

Our immigration debate needs that same sense of shared stake. Take the neighbourhood school. A newcomer whose child attends wants it to succeed just as much as the parent whose family has lived in the community for decades. They might disagree on the details, but both are equally invested in the outcome.

That’s why in many of the conversations I have these days, I keep returning to one question: what would it take for Canada’s next generation to live better than the last? 

It’s a question that newcomers, established immigrants, and Canadians by birth can all answer. It also asks us to define together what ‘better’ actually means: work that pays a decent wage, a home people can afford, and the time and security to raise a family, care for loved ones, or take part in community life.

Immigration would be one part of that conversation, alongside education, healthcare, housing, and all the other things that make a society work.

Of course, we might still argue about the Levels plan, but that argument would sit inside a bigger one about what kind of country we want to make possible. It could raise questions that headline polling numbers often skip. For example: if Canada recruits people for their skills, what has to happen for them to actually use those skills?

Canadian newcomers need to have a stake in the question

A shared stake only matters if newcomers or immigrants have a say in what happens next. Fatemeh Alhosseini, the Executive Director of Impakt Foundation for Social Change, showed me what that could look like when she joined me on The Newcomers Podcast.

Her team asked refugees in focus groups what they would do if they had all the money in the world to start a non-profit for newcomers. They expected people to talk about jobs and housing. Instead, almost everyone talked about building community and belonging in practical ways, like being able to ask someone a question and get the right answer.

That might sound small if you’ve never dealt with the huge amounts of information thrown at newcomers in their first few months in Canada. So Impakt hired some of these refugees, still living in shelters, to help design, deliver, and evaluate its programs.

Those individuals needed support, but they also knew things the organization didn’t. They didn’t have to finish settling into Canada or become a success story before their judgment counted.

At the 9th Metropolis Identities Conference panel I joined in October, when I was asked to add one word to the government’s immigration growth agenda, mine was participation. Because I believe with all my heart that people can help shape the places where they’re making a home, including disagreeing without it becoming a test of their gratitude. 

❝

Right now, it mostly gives us sides to pick from.

The friends we haven’t met yet

So yes, I think we can have a better Canadian immigration debate. But it starts with admitting that headline numbers don’t tell us what people are actually disagreeing about. It also means building the conversation around something newcomers, long-term residents, and Canadians by birth all have a stake in. And it means giving the people who’ve decided to make Canada their new home a real say in the answers we look for, even when they tell us things we didn’t expect.

In Pride’s ending, hundreds of miners show up to march alongside the activists at the 1985 London Pride march. In the film’s closing notes, it credits the National Union of Mineworkers' votes with helping lesbian and gay rights become part of the Labour Party’s policy plans. The people who were helped ended up shaping what came next for those who helped them. 

Dai called that kind of support the discovery of “a friend you never knew existed.” A better immigration debate would give Canadians and newcomers alike more of these friends.

Right now, it mostly gives us sides to pick from.

Before you go…

If you found this article helpful, you might also enjoy our weekly newsletter, From the Editor. It’s packed with tips, tools, stories, and guides to help immigrants settle in, find work, and become part of Canadian society.

Dozie Anyaegbunam | Managing Editor