Please send this to ONE Canadian immigrant today and ask them to subscribe here.
What do the Guac Mexi Grill in Moose Jaw and Balvir Singh have in common? Turns out quite a lot.
Both are in Saskatchewan. And on July 8th, 2026, after an investigation by the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA), Singh was given a conditional sentence of just under two years, fined $10,000, and ordered to complete 40 hours of community service. He pleaded guilty in the Saskatoon Court of King’s Bench to Counselling Misrepresentation under Section 126 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA).
Meanwhile, the Moose Jaw employer was fined $5,000 and had to pay an additional $12,000 after admitting he made a foreign worker pay to keep his job. This case was prosecuted under the Foreign Worker Recruitment and Immigration Services Act (FWRISA), which has now been replaced by the Immigration Services Act.
The Judge said the $5,000 fine, which was the highest allowed under the old law, was not enough to deter the employer’s 'atrocious' behaviour. The Judge also pointed out that the employee belonged to a vulnerable group.
The new law allows for much higher fines—up to $1.25 million—for corporations that break the rules. We will likely see cases in the future where these larger fines are used.
There are many other similar cases—some truly nightmarish. But most of them seem to be coming out of Saskatchewan because of the province’s Immigration Services Act. Saskatchewan is currently the only province with its own rules for recruiters, employers, and immigration consultants, though others like Alberta are planning to do the same.
The nightmarish, fraudulent world of payroll cycling
The CBSA calls the scheme that Singh and similar offenders ran payroll cycling, and it relies on selling jobs that don’t exist. An employer or a consultant, or sometimes both, manufactures pay stubs for a worker who holds a permit for a phantom job. The worker pays to look employed and then uses the pay stubs to file for permanent residency.
The Moose Jaw case is a textbook example of how the scheme works.
When the Guac Mexi Grill got new owners in August 2023, Parth Patel, a food supervisor, was told he had to pay $25,000 to keep his job. Patel was close to getting permanent residency and needed the job to keep his nomination, so he managed to negotiate the fee down to $12,000.
To create a false paper trail for immigration authorities, the employer issued pay stubs and made payments into Patel's account. He was then required to reimburse the employer after each pay period, successfully cycling his own money to buy the appearance of a full-time job.
Are you a victim, or could you be accused too?
The CBSA charged Singh with counselling misrepresentation, which means he advised someone to do it. But what happens to the immigrant who submitted an application with false documents?
According to IRCC, you are always responsible for what you submit, no matter what advice you got from a consultant, recruiter, or employee. That’s why we advise applicants to check every detail in their file before signing.
Section 40 and the risk of inadmissibility
The idea that you are legally responsible for any false information an immigration consultant submits for you comes from Section 40 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA). Section 40 lets the Canadian government take away your status, cancel your work permit, or order you to leave if you submit false information or hide important facts.
If fake documents or pay stubs are found, the CBSA and IRCC will ask: What did you know, and when did you find out?
If you knew the documents were fake, submitting them could lead to a finding of misrepresentation. This means you could face a mandatory five-year ban from Canada and be deported.
The Sunny Wang case is a good example. When the Richmond consultant’s fraud was uncovered, hundreds of his clients got removal orders and lost their permanent residency—even those who said they did not know about the full scheme. Taking bad advice from a fraudster does not protect you from Section 40. Submitting fake documents is a big risk for any immigration applicant.
Can you recover the money you paid?
If a worker paid $20,000, $40,000, or $50,000 for a fake job arrangement, their options for getting their money back are limited and, in many cases, non-existent.
The illegal contract rule: If a worker knew the arrangement was fake or illegal when they paid the money, Canadian courts won’t help them get it back. As demonstrated in Canadian case law—such as an Alberta court case where an Indian national lost $15,000 to an immigration "fixer"—the legal system won’t enforce an illegal contract or help a person who participated in an unlawful scheme.
Civil lawsuits: If a worker was genuinely deceived, filing a civil lawsuit is the only way to recover the money. But even that depends on who you hired to represent you.
Regulated professionals (Lawyers and RCICs): Licensed immigration consultants and lawyers are required by law to have professional liability insurance. This means there is a fund you can claim from if you win a lawsuit against them.
Unauthorized practitioners (Ghost consultants or UAPs): Unlicensed operators don’t have insurance. Suing an unlicensed ghost consultant almost never gets your money back because they often disappear or hide their assets. Once cash goes to an unauthorized practitioner, the money is usually gone for good.
What the regulators and courts can (and can’t) fix
The CICC (College of Immigration and Citizenship Consultants) regulates and disciplines licensed consultants. It does not give financial compensation to victims, and it cannot grant work permits or restore your immigration status. Most consumer complaints to the CICC are dismissed.
A civil court can order a licensed representative to pay you damages, but a judge cannot give you immigration status or stop you from being deported.
Negligence and fraud are different in law. Negligence is when a professional makes a careless mistake. Fraud is when they trick you on purpose. A consultant who leads a client into a fake job scheme is committing fraud.
What should you do if you realize mid-arrangement that your job is fake?
If you discover midway through a process that your job isn't real or that your consultant submitted manufactured documents, don’t walk away thinking that protects you. Quitting that sort of arrangement without reporting the scheme leaves the fraudulent paper trail in your IRCC file. This leaves you exposed to Section 40 misrepresentation charges if the fraud is discovered later during a government investigation.
Instead…
Keep all your evidence: Save text messages, WhatsApp chats, bank transfer records, cash receipts, and emails. Store them somewhere safe that only you can access, like a personal cloud drive, so the employer or consultant cannot access or delete them.
Get independent legal advice right away if you realize you are in an illegal scheme: A licensed immigration lawyer can review your case, help you leave the arrangement, and guide you on how to report the fraud to the authorities to protect yourself under Canadian law.
Report the scheme to the authorities: It is much better to come forward on your own than to be caught in a CBSA raid or investigation. If you wait and are caught taking part in payroll cycling, you could face criminal charges, inadmissibility, and immediate deportation.
What do you check for to avoid such schemes?
Here is what we recommend every worker check before giving anyone their hard-earned money:
Watch where the money goes: If a consultant asks you to pay for the Labour Market Impact Assessment (LMIA), that is almost always a red flag. The employer should pay for the assessment, not you. If anyone asks you to pay to keep a job or to cover a fee the employer should pay, you are likely being scammed.
Make sure your consultant is licensed, but don't trust that alone: Only a licensed consultant, lawyer, Quebec notary, or Ontario paralegal can legally charge for immigration advice. You can check the CICC public register to confirm a consultant’s license. But remember, having a license only means they can be reported. If a registered consultant tells you to give your employer cash for an assessment, they are breaking the law.
Check the employer’s record: The federal government has a public list of employers who have broken the rules of the Temporary Foreign Worker Program, along with their bans and fines. If your employer is on this list, do not proceed. Also, check provincial business registries to make sure the address is a real workplace, and be cautious if the employer only contacts you by personal cellphone.
So yeah, folks, if a job offer seems too good to be true, you should really investigate to make sure it's legitimate.
