Please forward this to ONE Canadian immigrant today and tell them to subscribe here.

The green zone topics are safe with anyone. The yellow zone topics requires some judgment about how far to take things. The red zone are topics to avoid entirely in casual conversation, especially when you're still getting to know someone.

That doesn't mean these subjects are permanently forbidden. As relationships deepen over months and years, some of them become fair game with close friends.

But in the early stages of getting to know colleagues, neighbours, or acquaintances, bringing up any of these can create discomfort, damage a professional relationship, or in some cases, lead to serious consequences.

Politics and elections

You have to be extremely careful because these are highly sensitive. People may have strong hidden opinions that they don't normally express. A casual comment can land very differently than you intended, and you may not find out until the relationship has already cooled.

The safest approach is to avoid political topics entirely in small talk. If the other person brings it up, you can listen and keep your response neutral, but don't assume that because someone seems friendly they want to hear your political views.

Religion, faith practices, and lifestyle

Canada is a diverse country. And being open and welcoming to people from all lifestyles, all family makeups, all gender identities is the expectation.

Which means any assumptions or jokes can hurt deeply. This is particularly true when it comes to lifestyles, meaning those who may be in same-sex relationships or have gender fluidity. Be mindful of negative comments or digging deeply in a way that seems intrusive. If a person volunteers information about their faith or their identity, that's fine to acknowledge. But don't probe.

Negative comments can be considered discrimination, lead to HR complaints, and can even result in legal proceedings.

Here’s one example. A recruiter posted about attending Pride Day, and a job seeker sent a message saying, "I'm surprised to learn that about you." That single comment sabotaged any chances that newcomer had of getting work opportunities through that recruiter. If you have personal opinions about different lifestyles and you express negativity towards them, that is not tolerated in Canada.

How much things cost (specific numbers)

Asking questions like "How much was your house?" seems very intrusive and rude. In the yellow zone, we discussed how you can talk about costs in general terms. But whenever you ask someone specifically how much something cost, you've crossed a line.

"Things are getting expensive" is a general observation. "What did you pay for that?" is a personal question most Canadians aren't comfortable answering outside of close relationships.

Gif by foilarmsandhog on Giphy

Personal finances and salaries

Save that for close relationships or formal career conversations where you're discussing compensation. That's obviously a different context. But in general small talk, avoid getting into personal salaries and personal finances.

Even if you're curious about salary ranges in your field, a casual conversation with a colleague is not the place to ask. There are other ways to find that information.

Immigration status or paperwork struggles

You don't want to ask someone, "What's your status?" or "Are you PR yet?" unless you're close friends. Based on your own experiences as newcomers, you're probably quite sensitive to that already. But be aware of it for others as well.

You know how it feels when someone reduces your presence in a country to a piece of paperwork. Don't do it to someone else in casual conversation.

Detailed health problems

Asking about or sharing detailed health problems feels very heavy and inappropriate for casual contexts, especially at work. People don't want to hear about medical procedures or chronic conditions during a coffee break, and they don't want to be asked about theirs.

This also includes relationship challenges you may be having with a significant other or your family. That level of personal detail belongs in close friendships, not in small talk.

Criticizing Canada or talking about how things are better back home

Speaking from the experience of having lived and worked abroad for several years, it's natural to feel a disconnect and question why certain things operate the way they do. Well, they don't work the way you're used to, and that's a normal part of adjusting to a new country.

But if you are making repeated negative comments about Canada or Canadian culture, or talking about how things are so much better back home, it can make people defensive. You've chosen to come here. Those who were born and raised here could be quite offended because you're insulting their home.

That's not to say Canada is perfect. The country has its challenges. But be very mindful of repeated negative comments. There's a difference between acknowledging that adjustment is hard and consistently putting down the place where the person you're talking to has lived their whole life.

Some questions to noodle on that help you practice all you've learned

Q1. Think about a topic from this list that would be completely normal small talk in your home country. Practice catching yourself before you bring it up this week. What would you say instead?

Q2. The next time someone brings up a red zone topic with you, practice keeping your response neutral and brief. What's a one-sentence reply that acknowledges what they said without deepening the conversation?

Q3. If you've already made a comment about Canada that might have come across as overly critical, think about how you could reframe that observation. How would you express the same feeling without putting the country or culture down?

Q4. Pay attention to which red zone topics come up most naturally for you in conversation. Are there one or two that you default to without thinking? Identifying them is the first step to catching them.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Keep Reading