
Rural Alberta | Bernard Spragg. NZ from Christchurch, New Zealand, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons
Every day, we all make small choices that don’t matter much in the long run. Rice, potatoes, or couscous? Brown or white rice? Baked, mashed, hash browns, or French fries? We pick based on taste, mood, or habit. We often make these decisions on a whim.
But these choices aren’t like applying for a job and getting hired. They’re not like marrying someone after a long engagement, building a life together, having children, and planning for retirement. They’re also not like leaving your home country to settle somewhere new, or serving on a jury or as a judge.
Those are serious, life-changing decisions that push us to think carefully and try to make the right choice.
We need to think things through and understand what we truly want, knowing we’ll have to live with the results for a long time.
Every voter deserves the right to honest information.
Living in a democracy really tests our ability to make big decisions. We have to ask ourselves if we can vote thoughtfully in elections and referendums. Some people choose not to vote at all. In Alberta, voter turnout has sometimes dropped to around 40% in provincial elections. In the recent referendum, tens of thousands skipped all ten questions.
Sadly, referendums give voters only a short time to decide on serious questions—issues that courts might spend years debating. Court decisions can be appealed, and laws can be changed, but referendum voters don’t get those chances.
Voters in elections and referendums act a bit like judges and juries. They’re deciding not just their own futures, but other people’s too. Their choices can’t be changed until the next election or another referendum.
If a referendum is rushed and the campaign is too short, people may make snap decisions they later regret. This can cause problems that are hard to fix. It’s even worse than making an impulse purchase.
All information about what might happen if people vote "yes" or "no" in a referendum should come from a neutral source. No outside interference should be allowed.
No partisans, politicians, interest groups, lobbyists, or other organizations should be allowed to advertise for or against "yes" or "no," or spread propaganda or false information about a referendum.
Every voter deserves the right to honest information. People should be able to vote with a clear mind, making their own choices based on real facts, not manipulation. Referendum questions should be short, clear, and easy for everyone to understand.
The immediate results of voting "yes" or "no" on each referendum question should be clearly listed and explained in simple, straightforward language. Voters shouldn’t be confused by theoretical, hypothetical, or imagined outcomes, whether positive or negative.
Clear referendums are fair to everyone and let voters use their best judgment. This way, people can express their wishes thoughtfully and clearly. But a poorly planned referendum can leave many voters disappointed and weaken trust in the process. For example, in B.C.’s first electoral reform referendum, most voters wanted change, but organizers required a 60% "yes" vote.
The majority was ignored. When a second referendum came, voters were lukewarm, likely feeling their push for reform didn’t matter. In the end, B.C.’s electoral reform was dropped.
In Québec, though, a simple 51% majority in a "yes" or "no" referendum could decide the future for all Canadians. Thankfully, both sides accepted the result.
Another problem with referendums is that politicians can use them to avoid responsibility for tough decisions or bad outcomes. For example, Metro Vancouver’s 2015 transportation referendum, backed by most of the region’s mayors, was defeated. Afterward, politicians stepped back from the issue.
A referendum is a serious matter and deserves careful attention from everyone involved, both organizers and voters.
In Alberta’s ten-question, non-binding referendum on October 19, 2026, voters rejected five questions and supported five. Each one was important and required careful thought.
The outcome of each question could have a big impact on everyone in Alberta, not just a few. Permanent residents and people born in Alberta but living elsewhere would also be affected, even though they couldn’t vote.
Alberta’s government wants to control Canada’s current “economic” immigration system.
Now, the provincial government might think it has a non-binding mandate to decide what happens next on its own. But there are complications to consider:
Question 1: The Québec provincial government gained immigration powers from 1971 to 1991, more than a hundred years after Canada was founded.
So how long would it take Alberta to do the same and get “increased control,” with agreement from the federal government and all the other provinces?
Alberta’s government wants to control Canada’s current “economic” immigration system. This system doesn’t seem to prioritize younger, hard-working people who could contribute for many years. Instead, it seems to favour those with lots of experience or money.
This approach favours well-established people in their home countries—often older and possibly less energetic—who can more easily qualify or afford to come to Canada. Unfortunately, they have fewer productive years left to contribute. Is this really the immigration policy Alberta wants?

Calgary Skyline from North near Kensington | Ash-M-Bishop, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons
Question 2: Provinces already determine eligibility for provincial programs and social services. Canadian citizens who stay out of a province for more than six months per year can lose provincial health insurance (and lose income tax “residency” status in Canada if living abroad).
If question 2 were implemented fairly, everyone in the province—including those already receiving provincial services—would have to prove their eligibility again.
This increases the risk of mistakes and could mean some eligible people lose their services by accident.
The question didn’t explain that everyone in Alberta—not just a few—would face more bureaucracy. Government spending could go up to reprocess all current recipients of provincial services.
Question 3: Provincial health insurance rules vary from province to province. Some charge everyone a health insurance fee. Provinces can give people moving to another province three months' coverage while qualifying for their new province’s health insurance. Provinces can give people up to 12 months' coverage during a temporary absence. Provinces can give former resident citizens who return from living abroad immediate coverage without a three-month waiting period.
During the 1980s, Ontario provided OHIP coverage to foreign university students on arrival, provided they met the province's residency requirements. During the same era in Québec, foreign university students studying French for three months received private health insurance coverage on arrival, arranged for them by the university. Maybe it's included in their tuition fees?
If question 3 became law, employers of temporary seasonal workers in Alberta would likely have to provide services the province doesn’t offer. This would count as a “benefit” and probably a business expense for tax purposes, but it would also mean more costs and work for employers.
Question 4: This might ease the burden and cost for employers from Question 3. But if temporary workers have to pay the “fee or premium” themselves, they might choose not to come to Alberta.
Temporary workers aren’t here to pay extra to support provincial services. They already pay federal and provincial taxes like everyone else.
(How would the province interpret a "yes" to 3 with a "no" to 4, or a "no" to 3 with a "yes" to 4?)
Question 5: This would require everyone to show government ID to vote. Does every eligible voter have this kind of document? If not, paying for one is like paying to vote.
Poll workers aren’t ID experts, just like bartenders checking age or shopkeepers spotting fake bills. Would the government need to buy machines for every polling station to check IDs? This would slow down voting, and machines can break. Election costs would go up.
Are there really so many illegitimate voters that it makes sense to slow down voting and spend more on "security"? It feels like all voters are being treated as suspects—guilty until proven innocent.
In reality, people always look for security, but perfect safety is impossible. Unexpected events happen. Trade wars or military conflicts can suddenly make life more expensive. Natural disasters occur. Accidents take lives.
So why spend time and money on something that might not even be a real problem?

Before you go…
If you found this article helpful, you might also enjoy our weekly newsletter, From the Editor. It’s packed with tips, tools, stories, and guides to help immigrants settle in, find work, and become part of Canadian society.
Dozie Anyaegbunam | Managing Editor